The dilemma

A guy in a bucket hat walks straight to the front. He leans over the counter and says something to the bartender. The bartender shrugs and starts pouring two cups. The people ahead of you go quiet. Someone behind you mutters. The bartender is on the second cup.

Your options

1. "Mate, queue is back there."
2. Lean to the person next to you. "Are you serious?"
3. Find the right words in your head.